The correct puppet order
In the family puppet theater in Remothered: Red Nun’s Legacy, arrange the four figures left to right: Mother → Father → Son → Daughter. Both Into Indie Games and a separate puzzle walkthrough describe that placement. Do not arrange them by the order in which you happened to collect them.
What you need before the puzzle
You must have collected all four puppets. In the late-game sequence, the broken Mother Puppet must be repaired at the workshop before it can be placed. The Son Puppet is found later in the garage using Retrocognition. If a figure is missing, the order alone cannot unlock the theater.
Place the family
- Return to the theater room and wait for a safe chance to interact if the Stalker is still nearby.
- Examine the family letter. Use Retrocognition to hear or see the clue about the family’s order.
- Put the Mother in the far-left position.
- Place the Father immediately to her right, followed by the Son.
- Place the Daughter at the far-right position.
- After all four are in place, look for the newly opened secret passage to the left of the theater.
Secret passage not opening?
First check whether all four figures are actually present. Missing the repaired Mother or the garage Son is a collection problem, not a different arrangement. Next, check that you are viewing the four slots from the front and that Mother is on the left. The separate source walkthroughs agree on the order; they do not report alternate permutations between difficulty levels.
Sources and proof scope
- Into Indie Games, Part 4 — end-of-puzzle sequence and secret passage.
- Thumb Wars, all puppets and metronome — independent description of the four-puppet order.
Checked November 2, 2026. Original explanatory graphic only; no claim of firsthand GGClue gameplay footage.